A Comparative Study to Assess behavioural Problems in Preschoolers of working and Non working mothers from a selected Urban Community in Kachery, Thrissur

 

Amitha Abraham1, Annmary K. S2, Geena George1, Josna Augustine1*, Merlin George1,

Ambili Ulahannan2, Seeja Jacob3, Angela Gnanadurai4

1III Year BSC (N) Students*, Jubilee Mission College of Nursing, Thrissur.

2Lecturer, Jubilee Mission College of Nursing, Thrissur,

3Asst. Professor, Jubilee Mission College of Nursing, Thrissur.

4Professor, Jubilee Mission College of Nursing, Thrissur.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: josnaaugustine2@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

Title of the study: A comparative study to assess behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers from a selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur. Introduction: A large number of children suffer from behavioural problems at ltheir development stage. Mothers should able to detect any behavioural changes at the earliest Objective: Assess the behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur. Compare behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers from selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur. Associate selected behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers of selected demographic variable. Material and Methodology: The study was conducted among preschoolers of 70 working and 70 non working mothers. The research design of the study was descriptive comparative design and sample was selected by non-probability purposive sampling. Tool: The tool consists of 2 sections: Section A deals with A-socio demographic and clinical data and Section B consist of likert scale to assess behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers. Result: Socio-demographic and clinical data variables shows that 22(31.4%) children from age group 3 years, while 18(25.7%) and 7(10%) children are from 5 years and less than 6 years respectively. In non working mothers, 30(42.9%) children are from age group 3 years whereas 19(27.1%) children from age group 4 years while 11(15.1%) and 10(14.3%) are from age group 5 years and less than 6 years respectively. In working mothers, 33(47.1%) children are males whereas 37(52.9%) are females. In non working mothers, 37(52.9%) children are females while 33(47.1%) are males. In working mothers, 0(0.0 %) mothers are illiterate 4(5.7 %) mothers have primary education while 8(11.4%) mothers have secondary education, 38(54.3 %) mothers are graduated and 20(28.6 %) mothers have professional education. In non working mothers, 1(1.4 %) mothers are illiterate whereas 12(17.1 %) mothers have primary education while 30(42.49 %) mothers have secondary education and 4(5.7 %) mothers have professional education. Assessment of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers shows, mild behavioural problem seen in children of working mothers 64(91.429%) which is significantly more than the non working mothers 53(75.714%). Moderate behavioural problems are seen in preschoolers of working mothers 2(2.857%). None of the preschoolers of non working mothers have moderate behavioural problems. 4(5.714%) preschoolers of working mother have no behavioural problems whereas 17(24.286%) preschoolers of non working mothers have no behavioural problems. None of the preschoolers are affected with severe behavioural problems in both groups. In this study, there is significant association of education of mothers with selected behavioural problems. Discussion: Preschoolers of working mothers have more behavioural problems than those of non working mothers. Nurse can play amajor role in diminishing the behavioural problems by providing guidelines and counselling for the mothers. More interventional studies need to be conducted to reduce occurrence of the behavioural problems in preschoolers.

 

KEYWORDS: Preschooler, working mother, non working mother, behavioural problem.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

Children are the inheritance from God. They are likely clay in the potter’s hand. Handled with love and care, they create something, or else they will break. Mothers are more responsible for the intellectual development of the children. Parents know what is best fro their child and strong parent child relationship can help for a better outcome for children.1Preschoolers means, a child who is not old enough to go to school or a pupil attending preschool. Preschool age ranges typically two and half to four and half years old.2 Period between age 3 and 5 is one of extreme rapid developmental change and young children make these transitions with varying degree of speed and ease. Preschoolers commonly experience night time fears and night mares. In addition sleep walking and sleep terrors peak during preschoolers age.3

 

British child and adolescent mental health (CAMH) survey carried out by the office of National Statistics (ONS) in 1999 and 2004, comprising 7977 interviews from parents, children and teacher, found the prevalence of MHD among CYP to be 6% for conduct problems, 4% emotional problem (Depression or Anxiety) and 1.5% for hyper kinetic Disorder. Study conducted on behavioural problems among preschoolers in Delhi revealed that 22% children has behavioural problem. National survey says that there are marked changes in impatient children experience anger.4

 

Ehsan Ullah Syed and Sadia Mahmud in 2007 conducted a cross sectional survey to assess the emotional and behavioural problems amongst preschoolers in Karachi. About 1488 consent form were sent to 700 parents of private school and 788 of community school children. The response rate was 45.4% about 47% were rated as normal. 19% as borderline and 34%as abnormal by parents. The odds of female children of being normal was 1.5 times relative to male children Prevalence was higher amongst children attending community schools 5.

 

OBJECTIVES:

·       To assess the behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers from a selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur.

·       To compare behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers from a selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur.

·       To associate selected behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers of selected demographic variables.

 

MATERIALS AND METHODS:

Research approach:

Quantitative approach is used in this study.

 

Research design:

Descriptive comparative design to be used.

 

Setting:

Study conducted in a selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur.

 

Population:

It consist of preschoolers of working and non working mothers of selected urban community in Kachery, Thrissur.

 

Sample and sample size:

All working and non working mothers of preschooler children in selected urban community in Kachery. In this study, sample size is 70 working mothers and 70 non working mothers of preschooler children.

 

Sampling technique:

Non probability purposive sampling is used in this study.

 

Description and scoring of data collection tools:

Section A:

Socio demographic and clinical data questionnaire

This section has 14 questions regarding the socio demographic and clinical data such as age of the child, gender of the child, birth order of the child, height of the child, weight of the child, number of sibling, age of mother, education of mother, employment status of mother, working and travelling hours of mother, care taker of child, employment status of father.

 

Section B:

Likert scale to assess behavioural problems in Preschoolers

The researcher developed a Likert scale to assess the behavioural problems in preschoolers and it consists of 17 questions regarding the common behavioural problems seen in preschoolers, categorized under sub headings habit problems, speech problems, sleep problems and eating problems. Each item has five responses: never, rarely, sometimes, often, always and scores alloted are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 respectively.

 

Data Analysis and Interpretation:

Table 1: Demographic profile of preschoolers of working and non working mothers. (n=140)

Sl.No

Variables

Working

Non working

 

 

Frequency

%

Frequency

%

I.

Age of child

 

 

 

 

1.

3 years

22

31.4

30

42.9

2.

4years

23

32.9

19

27.1

3.

5years

18

25.7

11

15.1

4.

<6 years

7

10

10

14.3

II.

Gender of the child

 

 

 

 

1.

Male

33

47.1

33

47.1

2.

Female

37

52.9

37

52.9

III.

Birth order of the child

 

 

 

 

1.

1

26

37.1

35

50.0

2.

2

34

48.6

24

34.3

3.

3 and above

10

14.3

11

15.7

IV.

Height of the child

 

 

 

 

1.

Less than 90.5cm

6

8.6

6

8.6

2.

90.5-115cm

59

84.3

57

81.4

3.

Greater than 115cm

5

7.1

7

10

V.

Weight of the child

 

 

 

 

1.

Less than 12.5kg

10

14.3

19

27.1

2.

12.5 – 21.4

55

78.6

49

70.0

3.

More than 21.4kg

5

7.1

2

2.9

Vl.

Number of siblings

 

 

 

 

1.

1

42

60.0

38

54.3

2.

2

15

21.4

18

25.7

3.

3 and above

1

1.4

2

2.9

4.

None

12

17.1

12

17.1

Vll.

Age of mother

 

 

 

 

1.

18-23

1

1.4

4

5.7

2.

24-29

23

32.9

30

42.9

3.

30-35

40

57.1

31

44.3

4.

36 and above

6

8.6

5

7.1

VIII.

Education of mother

 

 

 

 

1.

Illiterate

0

0.0

1

1.4

2.

Primary education

4

5.7

12

17.1

3.

Secondary education

8

11.4

30

42.9

4.

Graduate

38

52.3

23

32.9

5.

Professional education

20

28.6

4

5.7

IX.

Employment status of mother

 

 

 

 

1.

House wife

0

0.0

70

100

2.

Government employee

6

8.6

0

0.0

3.

Private employee

61

87.1

0

0.0

4.

Daily wage earner

3

4.3

0

0.0

X.

Working and traveling hours of the mother

 

 

 

 

1.

6-8hours

46

65.7

0

0.0

2.

12hours and above

2

2.9

0

0.0

XI.

Care taker of the  child, If mother is working

 

 

 

 

1.

Creche

23

32.9

0

0.0

2.

Grand parents

46

65.7

0

0.0

3.

Neighbour

1

1.4

0

0.0

Xll.

Employment status of father

 

 

 

 

1.

Government employee

7

10

4

5.7

2.

Private employee

31

44.3

30

42.9

3.

Daily wage earner

17

20.0

21

30.0

4.

Business

13

18.6

15

21.4

5.

Any other

5

7.1

0

0.0

XIII.

Whether your child has any co-morbidities

 

 

 

 

1.

Yes

9

12.9

5

7.1

2.

No

61

87.1

65

92.9

XIV.

Whether child was preterm baby

 

 

 

 

1.

Yes

6

8.6

8

11.4

2.

No

64

91.4

62

88.6

 

The table 1 shows, in this study majority children of working mothers 23(32.9%) are from age group 4 years whereas 22(31.4%) children from age group 3 years, while 18 (25.7%) and 7(10%) children are from 5 years and less than 6 years respectively. In non working mothers, 30 (42.9%) children are from age group 3 years whereas 19(27.1%) children from age group 4 years while 11(15.1%) and 10( 14.3%) are from age group 5 years and less than 6 years respectively. In working mothers, 33(47.1%) children are males whereas 37(52.9%) are females. In non working mothers, 37(52.9%) children are females while 33(47.1%) are males. In working mothers, 0(0.0 %) mothers are illiterate 4(5.7 %) mothers have primary education while 8(11.4%) mothers have secondary education, 38(54.3 %) mothers are graduated and 20(28.6%) mothers have professional education .In non working mothers, 1(1.4 %) mothers are illiterate whereas 12(17.1%) mothers have primary education while 30(42.49%) mothers have secondary education and 4(5.7%) mothers have professional education.

 

Table 2: Identification of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers.(n=140)

Sl.

No.

Structured parental response inventory on selected behavioural problems in preschoolers

Working mothers

(n=70)

Non working mothers

(n=70)

 

 

f

%

f

%

1.

1-21(normal)

4

5.714

17

24.286

2.

22-42(mild)

64

91.429

53

75.714

3.

43- 63(moderate)

2

2.857

0

0

4.

>64(severe)

0

0

0

0

 

Majority of preschool children of working mothers 64(91.429%) have mild behavioural problems, 2(2.857%) preschool children have moderate behavioural problems and 4(5.714%) sample have no behavioural problem. Majority of preschool children of non working mothers 53(75.714%) have mild behavioural problems, 17(24.286%) preschool children have no behavioural problems and none of the preschooler children of non working mother have moderate behavioural problem.None of the preschoolers are affected with severe behavioural problems in both groups.

 

Table 3: Analysis of comparison of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers (n=140)

Components

Mean

SD

t

df

p

Working

30.31

6.097

9.312

138

0.0001*

Non working

22.97

2.519

 

 

 

 

Table 3 shows that mean of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working mothers is greater than main of non working mothers. t test was used to know any significant difference between the behavioural problems in in preschoolers of working and non working mothers. The calculated t value (9.312) is greater than tabular t value (1.9773) and p value less than 0.05. Hence research hypothesis H1 is accepted. This shows preschoolers of working mothers have more behavioural problems than preschoolers of non working mothers.

 

Table 4 shows that mean, standard deviation of habit problems, speech problems, sleep problems and eating problems of preschoolers of working mothers is higher than that of preschoolers of non working mothers.

 

Figure: 1 Comparison of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers

 


Table 4: Comparison of mean standard deviation and t value of each behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and non working mothers. (n=140)

Components

Working

Non working

 

 

Mean

SD

Mean

SD

t Value

df

P value

Habit problems

12.56

3.206

9.69

2.026

6.335

138

0.0001*

Speech problems

5.94

2.134

4.84

1.125

3.808

138

0.0001*

Sleep problems

5.31

1.790

3.93

0.997

5.658

138

0.0002*

Eating problems

6.50

2.013

2.013

1.012

7.204

138

0.0001*

 

Table 5: Association of behavioural problems with selected demographic variables (n=140)     

Sl No.

Demographic

Variables

Behavioural problems

 

 

 

X

df

p

value

 

 

Frequency

Percentage

Frequency

Percentage

 

 

 

I.

Age of child

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

3 years

22

31.4%

30

42.9%

3.83

3

0.280

 

4 years

23

32.9%

19

27.1%

 

 

 

 

5 years

18

25.7%

11

15.7%

 

 

 

 

>6years

7

10%

10

14.3%

 

 

 

II.

Age of mother

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

18-23years

1

1.4%

4

5.7%

3.96

3

0.266

 

24-29years

23

32.9%

30

42.9%

 

 

 

 

30-35years

40

57.1%

31

44.3%

 

 

 

 

36 and above

6

8.6%

5

7.14%

 

 

 

III.

Education of mother

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Illiterate

0

0%

1

1.4%

32.09

4

0.01

 

Primary education

4

5.7%

12

17.1%

 

 

 

 

Secondary education

8

11.4%

30

12.9%

 

 

 

 

Graduate

38

54.3%

23

32.1%

 

 

 

 

Professional

20

28.6%

4

5.7%

 

 

 

Significant at p<0.05


 

Table 5 shows thatthere is significant association (p<0.05) with behavioural problems in preschoolers and education of mother and there is no significant association of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and nonworking mothers with selected sociodemographic variables. Educated mothers are mostly working. This study specifically brings out that higher the educational status of the mothers (working and non working), more the behavioural problems in their children.

 

RESULT AND DISCUSSION:

Preschool children of working mothers has more behavioural problems as compared to preschool children of non working mothers. The findings of the study is supported by a comparative study conducted by Mrs. Alexander. A, Asha .P (2014), on “behavioural problems of preschool children among working and non working mothers”. Based on the present study, the investigator found that majority preschool children of working mothers (64) 91.429% has mild behavioural problems. Hence it is concluded that preschool children of working mothers has more behavioural as compared to preschool children of non working mothers6. Reshma Laxman and Megha Chhagan Khade in 2016 conducted a comparative study to assess the problems among the preschooler of working and non working mothers. The result showed that the health problems are more in working mothers child as compared to non working mothers in which 50% of children have psychosocial problems, 32% of children have attention deficit/hyperactivity problems and 18% have emotional behavioural disorders.7

 

Mild behavioural problems were seen in children of working mothers 64(91.429%) which is significantly more than the non working mothers 53(75.714%). Moderate behavioural problems were seen in preschoolers of working mothers 2(2.857%), none of preschoolers of working mothers have moderate behavioural problems. 4(5.714%) of preschoolers of working mothers have no behavioural problems whereas 17(24.286%) preschoolers of non working mothers have no behavioural problems. There is significant association (p<0.05) with behavioural problems in preschoolers and education of mother and there is no significant association of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and nonworking mothers with selected sociodemographic variables. Educated mothers are mostly working. This study specifically brings out that higher the educational status of the mothers (working and non working), more the behavioural problems in their children.

 

CONCLUSION:

Major conclusion drawn from the study are: majority children of working mothers 23(32.9%) are from age group 4 years whereas 22(31.4%) children from age group 3 years, while 18 (25.7%) and 7(10%) children are from 5 years and less than 6 years respectively. In non working mothers, 30(42.9%) children are from age group 3 years whereas 19(27.1%) children from age group 4 years while 11(15.1%) and 10(14.3%) are from age group 5 years and less than 6 years respectively. Mild behavioural problems were seen in children of working mothers 64(91.429%) which is significantly more than the non working mothers 53(75.714%). Moderate behavioural problems were seen in preschoolers of working mothers 2(2.857%), none of preschoolers of working mothers have moderate behavioural problems. 4(5.714%) of preschoolers of working mothers have no behavioural problems whereas 17(24.286%) preschoolers of non working mothers have no behavioural problems. There is significant association (p<0.05) with behavioural problems in preschoolers and education of mother and there is no significant association of behavioural problems in preschoolers of working and nonworking mothers with selected sociodemographic variables. Educated mothers are mostly working. This study specifically brings out that, higher the educational status of the mothers (working and non working), more the behavioural problems in their children.

 

REFERENCE:

1.      Data P. Pediatric nursing. 2nd edition. New Delhi: Jaypee brothers medical publishers (p) Ltd; 2009

2.      D Melvin L, B William C, C Allen C. Developmental-behavioural pediatrics. 3rd edition. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders; 1999.

3.      Encyclopedia Britannica O. Eating disorder [Internet]. [Cited 30 September 2020]. Available from: https://www.britannica.com/science/eating-disorders

4.      Rai S, Malik S, Sharma D. Behavioural problems among preschool children. Indian pediatrics. 1993; 4:475-478.

5.      Syed Ullah E, Mahmud S. Cross sectional survey to assess the emotional and behavioural problems amongst preschoolers in Karachi [Internet].researchgate.2007 [cited 18october 2007].Available from: http://www.researchgate.net.

6.      Alexander A. Study to assess behavioural problems among preschoolers [Internet]. Researchgate. 2006 [cited 29 March 2006]. Available from: http://www.researchgate.net

7.      Laxman R, Khade M. Comparative study to assess the problems among the preschoolers of working and non working mothers. [Internet].researchgate.2016[cited 20 may 2016].Available from: http://www.researchgate.net

 

 

 

Received on 15.03.2022         Modified on 10.07.2022

Accepted on 12.10.2022       ©A&V Publications All right reserved

Int.  J. of Advances in Nur. Management. 2023; 11(1):4-8.

DOI: 10.52711/2454-2652.2023.00002